Win Report: How cutting overwhelm grew conversions by 13%
Win Reports help you grow your business by showing our methodology at work. Each Win Report showcases a real-world test, sharing the research, insights, and techniques that led to the win.

Churnet Valley Railway is a heritage steam railway running through the Staffordshire Moorlands in the UK. Almost entirely volunteer-run, it holds a 4.8‑star rating on Trustpilot from more than 8,000 reviews.

Research: Too much food for thought
If you’ve read our Churnet Valley case study, you’ll know that participants in our user tests found the overall site “boring” and “out of date.” Rather than redesign it in one irreversible swoop, we identified the key pages, and began scientifically validating our changes on the highest‑value areas.
One such focus was the Dining Experiences listing page, where visitors compare the numerous different dining options available—everything from cream teas to Indian dining. The problem, as these scrollmaps illustrate, was that many users were never seeing all the options.

The data showed that fewer than one in five visitors reached the bottom of the page, and our user testers helped us see why. The page was hard cognitive work. To make a decision to book, a visitor had to compare each offering in terms of the particular food on offer, the days and times that experience ran, and the price. We watched as users scrolled up and down the page (especially on mobile) trying to hold numerous competing facts in their heads.
A high proportion of our test participants used a very specific word to describe the page… “overwhelming.”
This is what behavioral scientists call the Paradox of Choice. When faced with too many options, decision‑makers freeze, defer, or abandon the decision entirely. The page wasn’t failing to inform. It was failing to make choosing feel easy.
How could we redesign the listing to make it more attractive to modern audiences, and less work for decision‑makers?
The original page (or control)
The original page contained a long vertical stack of eight dining experiences, each with a photo, a tagline, a paragraph of description, and departure info.

The tested page (or variation)
For the variation, we redesigned the page using elements of the previous wins, and made it easier for visitors to identify and compare the most popular experiences.

The specific changes included:
- A hero that leads with the value proposition: In addition to the welcoming hero image, we rewrote the introduction copy: “Trade the usual restaurant view for rolling countryside and the hiss of a vintage whistle, on the UK’s only steam railway where every dish is crafted with care…” The Tripadvisor badge and certifications now feature on the image, with the Trustpilot rating immediately below.
- Categorized sections: “Our Most Popular Dining Experiences,” “Lunch Trains,” “Evening Meals Onboard.” Replacing the flat stack of eight with curated groupings put the highest‑performing experiences in front of the largest share of visitors—directly tackling the scroll fall‑off the research had revealed.
- Smaller, comparable cards in a row: Each experience now sits in its own compact card with a photograph, a short description, and bulleted facts (price, departure time, duration) with icons—so visitors could weigh three or four options side by side instead of scrolling past one card after another.
- A safe‑step booking CTA: The heatmap had shown visitors clicking “More Information” almost two‑and‑a‑half times as often as “Book Now.” We replaced “Book Now” with “Check Running Times”—a smaller mental commitment that still leads straight into the booking flow. (See our article on The Safe Step Principle.)
Although mobile users still saw the experiences in a column, they still benefited from wider design improvements, categorized sections, and improved information.

Result: Conversions increased by 13%
During the test, we observed a 13% increase in conversions, with the effect even more pronounced for first‑time visitors. A result we were chuffed about.
This is just one of many tests we ran for Churnet Valley Railway as part of a research‑led redesign program.
Here’s what our client had to say


Greg Wilson, General Manager, Churnet Valley Railway
“Since we started working with CRE, every single dining train we’ve operated in 2026 has been full. That’s broken the million‑pound barrier for the first time ever. That’s income. We've never achieved that. We've never been close.”
You can also watch the full video testimonial from Churnet Valley Railway:
What’s next
As usual, we added the test to our proprietary Wins Database, then looked for ways to apply its lessons to other parts of Churnet Valley Railway’s business and then to other clients.
If you want us to grow your profits—quickly and efficiently—check if you qualify for a free one‑on‑one strategy session with one of our CRO consultants.
We’ll only work with you if we believe we can get amazing results together. Our success has come entirely from positive word of mouth, and we plan to keep it that way.
Thanks to Churnet Valley Railway for letting us share these insights (and for being such a great team to work with).
How much did you like this article?
What’s your goal today?
1. Hire us to grow your company
We’ve generated hundreds of millions for our clients, using our unique CRE Methodology™. To discover how we can help grow your business:
- Read our case studies, client success stories, and video testimonials.
- Learn about us, and our unique values, beliefs and quirks.
- Visit our “Services” page to see the process by which we assess whether we’re a good fit for each other.
- Schedule your FREE website strategy session with one of our renowned experts.
Schedule your FREE strategy session
2. Learn how to do conversion
Download a free copy of our Amazon #1 best-selling book, Making Websites Win, recommended by Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Moz, Econsultancy, and many more industry leaders. You’ll also be subscribed to our email newsletter and notified whenever we publish new articles or have something interesting to share.
Browse hundreds of articles, containing an amazing number of useful tools and techniques. Many readers tell us they have doubled their sales by following the advice in these articles.
Download a free copy of our best-selling book
3. Join our team
If you want to join our team—or discover why our team members love working with us—then see our “Careers” page.
4. Contact us
We help businesses worldwide, so get in touch!
© 2026 Conversion Rate Experts Limited. All rights reserved.
A Brandwidth Group Company.










